Can a Lawyer Defend Someone They Know is Guilty?

Facing criminal charges is a daunting experience that thrusts defendants into the complexities of the legal system. For both defendants and their attorneys, navigating this maze requires a nuanced understanding of the dichotomy between factual guilt—believed or known facts—and legal guilt, which is determined within the courtroom by the evidence and legal argumentation.

Every individual accused of a crime is guaranteed certain rights, including the right to a fair trial and zealous legal representation under the U.S. Constitution. Below, we go into the ethical dilemmas and responsibilities faced by defense attorneys, who must uphold these rights while embodying integrity and professionalism, even when they suspect or know that their client may have committed the crime in question.

If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges, contact The Defenders. Our team of experienced attorneys is dedicated to providing the best legal representation for our clients, no matter the situation.

The Defendant’s Dilemma

Many individuals facing criminal charges often fear that if they confess to their lawyer about their guilt or involvement, their lawyer may abandon them or be less dedicated to securing an acquittal. Even if a defendant chooses to remain silent, they may worry that their lawyer assumes they are guilty.

However, what your lawyer thinks or believes about your guilt is not necessarily relevant to the defense strategy. As a defendant, it is crucial to understand that the ultimate decision of guilt lies within the legal system and that you are entitled to certain rights and protections provided by the U.S. Constitution.

In criminal cases, that means it is up to the prosecution to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that you are guilty of the crime you have been charged with. This is where your defense attorney—whether you choose to retain a private attorney or a public defender—plays a crucial role in ensuring that your rights are protected and that due process is followed.

Understanding Guilt: Factual Guilt vs. Legal Guilt

When discussing guilt, it is essential to differentiate between factual and legal guilt.

Factual guilt refers to a person’s actual involvement in the crime they have been accused of, while legal guilt is determined by the court based on evidence and arguments presented. It is important to note that even if someone may be factually guilty, it does not necessarily mean they are legally guilty.

Regardless of the crime committed, a defendant is not considered legally guilty until the prosecutor presents sufficient evidence to convince a judge or jury of a conviction. More on this below.

However, the defendant must be on the same page with their lawyer about the details.

The lawyer cannot lie to the judge by falsely stating the defendant did not commit certain acts if they are aware of the defendant’s actual actions. Additionally, a lawyer cannot admit guilt if the defendant chooses not to. A skilled lawyer’s trial strategy should concentrate on highlighting the prosecution’s inability to prove all elements of the alleged crime.

The Role of Evidence in Criminal Cases

Evidence plays a central role in establishing legal guilt in criminal cases. The prosecution bears the burden of proving the defendant’s guilt, and it is their responsibility to present evidence that meets the legal standard of beyond a reasonable doubt.

The defense lawyer’s job is to challenge this evidence, question its validity, and present alternative explanations or interpretations. This process ensures that every person facing criminal charges receives a fair trial and is not wrongfully convicted based on weak or insufficient evidence.

Lawyers Must Provide Zealous Representation

One of the fundamental ethical duties of a defense attorney is to provide zealous representation for their clients. This means advocating for them passionately and diligently, regardless of personal beliefs about their guilt or innocence.

The ABA’s Model Code of Responsibility emphasizes that a defense lawyer must “zealously represent their client within the bounds of the law.” This principle reflects the lawyer’s fundamental role in assisting the public with their legal cases.

In simpler terms, this means that even if a defense attorney believes their client is guilty, they must still work tirelessly to defend them within the bounds of ethical and legal standards. Although popular culture may detest the work that criminal lawyers do, the function of a lawyer is crucial in order to maintain justice and ensure fair outcomes for anyone that is facing legal charges.

The Attorney-Client Privilege

One of the core aspects of lawyer-client relationships is confidentiality. Anything you discuss with your defense attorney, regardless of guilt or innocence, is protected by attorney-client privilege. This means that your lawyer cannot disclose any information to anyone without your permission, except in specific circumstances (such as preventing imminent harm). This privilege allows clients to be open and honest with their lawyers without fear of repercussions.

Defense attorneys have a legal duty to safeguard all information shared by their clients. This obligation is crucial for fostering trust and maintaining confidentiality in the lawyer-client relationship. Breaching this principle can lead to disciplinary action and damage the lawyer’s reputation and credibility.

The Crucial Role of Defense Attorneys

Defense attorneys play an essential role in upholding the justice system and ensuring fair trials for all individuals accused of crimes. Their advocacy contributes to protecting constitutional rights and preserving justice and fairness in the legal system.

Without competent defense attorneys, defendants may be at risk of being wrongfully convicted or unfairly punished.

Truthfully, a defense lawyer almost never really knows whether the defendant is guilty or not of the charged crime. Even if the defendant claims guilt, he may not actually be guilty and could be lying to protect someone else.

The defendant may have performed the act that they were charged with, but the client may have a strong defense that would exonerate him. Due to these reasons, it is likely that the defense lawyer does not ask their client whether or not they actually committed the crime. Rather, a good lawyer uses facts to put on the best defense possible and leaves the question of guilt to the judge or jury.

The Right to Refuse a Case

While defense attorneys are obligated to provide zealous representation for their clients, they also have the right to refuse a case. Lawyers can refuse to defend someone for a variety of reasons, they are not likely to do so based on whether they are guilty or not guilty.

Some of these reasons are as follows:

• Defendant’s inability to pay for legal services: representing a client is a lawyer’s job, but it also requires financial compensation. If a defendant cannot afford the legal fees, the attorney may not be able to take on their case.
• Conflict of interest: if taking on a new case would create a conflict of interest with an existing or previous client, the defense attorney has an ethical obligation to decline representation.
• Insufficient expertise in the area of law: defense attorneys are expected to have knowledge and experience in criminal law. If they lack expertise in a specific area, they may refuse to take on a case that could potentially harm their client’s chances of receiving a fair trial.
• Personal beliefs or moral conflicts: while lawyers must provide zealous representation, they also have their own personal beliefs and moral codes. If a case goes against their principles, it is within their rights to refuse it.

In addition, lawyers also have have the right to withdraw from a case if unforeseen circumstances arise or if their client’s actions compromise the lawyer’s ability to represent them effectively.

Facing Criminal Charges? Hire The Defenders

If you or a loved one are facing criminal charges, it is crucial to seek the help of a skilled defense attorney. The consequences of a conviction can be life-altering, and having an experienced lawyer by your side can significantly impact the outcome of your case.

At The Defenders, we understand the importance of providing zealous representation for our clients and upholding their constitutional rights. Our team of dedicated lawyers has years of experience defending individuals accused of crimes and fighting for justice in the legal system.

Regardless of whether you are guilty or innocent, everyone deserves a fair trial and strong legal representation. Remember, you are innocent until proven guilty, and we will work tirelessly to defend your innocence. So don’t hesitate, The Defenders are here to help!

Contact us today for a free consultation and let us fight for your rights.

Frequently Asked Questions